How big brands get social media marketing completely wrong

Disclosure: Just so you know, we may sometimes earn a small commission from affiliate links on this site.

Big brands, especially ones in trendy, fashionable industries should be killing it when it comes to social media marketing, right?

Actually, there's fairly obvious evidence that they are wasting a lot of money on social marketing campaigns that are not generating returns.

This is good news for smaller businesses that are prepared to use social media correctly, because it levels the playing field for those without endless budgets.

This article will highlight how one brand that should be mopping up the social media arena is visibly floundering. I'll then contrast this with some strategies on how to get your social marketing working properly, in order to start generating great returns on your investment.

Social marketing: You're doing it wrong!

Garnier is a leading cosmetics brand that produces hair care and skin products - arguably a niche industry that should be really, really popular on social media.

Garnier USA a pretty successful mass market cosmetics business and, from the plethora of high budget, slick commercials they produce, they are obviously no strangers to traditional marketing.

But traditional marketing is just that - traditional.

The online world is completely different because people are no longer captive audiences.

If they don't like what they're watching or reading, something else is only a click away.

This alters the equation because instead of delivering a message, you have to deliver something of value in return for users' attention.

This is where Garnier are doing it wrong.

Advertising vs. engagement

Online promotions are all about content. It doesn't matter whether you are writing a blog or running a social media campaign for a global brand.

You have to produce content that:

  1. is focused on a target audience
  2. offers something of value
  3. is interesting and engaging

Traditional marketing, on the other hand, simply delivers a message - the more often it is shown, the more likely it will be to sink in.

The difference being that a traditional strategy (as used by Garnier) "tells" people something. Content "engages with" people about something.

The problem with content is that it takes time to build up trust and authority. You have to consistently and persistently be creative and thoughtful about the value your content offers.

This is what most people don't like about inbound marketing, because the returns are generated over time, and are kind of "vague" and "fuzzy". They can't be plugged into a nice formula and presented to the investors.

Proof that Garnier is doing it wrong

So let's consider two alternate universes, one in which Garnier is applying proper, content based engagement strategies to their YouTube campaign, and this universe.

How would we distinguish between the two?

Evidence of social success

Well, consider the alternate universe in which Garnier has invested their resources into creating lots of really cool videos on how to style your hair, or expert tips and advice on making your skin radiant, etc.

Assuming they were doing a good job, one would expect them to have:

  1. many channel subscribers
  2. each video with many views
  3. videos attracting lots of comments and likes

In addition, one should be able to track the steady growth in popularity of their content channel - something which is the hallmark of well implemented, content based campaigns.

Garnier's social campaign

Let's take a look at Garnier's YouTube channel, to see how it matches up:

  • Approx 4 500 subscribers
  • Average views of approx 2 500 per clip
  • Most popular clip has 8.8 million views

Ok, so on the surface of things it might seem like they have a small but active social media channel. But let's dig a little deeper.

Their most popular clip obtained nearly nine million views:

In order to pay for a few million views, you are looking at about $100 000 - but feel free to correct me if you know different. And, what's worse, out of all those viewers only about 30 people bothered to like the clip.

This is strong evidence of absolutely no engagement whatsoever. And why should there be? The clip is an advert.

Taken together, you can be pretty sure that Garnier is spending a lot of money for very little ROI (Return On Investment).

I don't mean to pick only on Garnier - in fact, many (if not most) big brands get social wrong. It's just that Garnier is in an industry that is so easy to get right online - it's visual, exciting, well understood, established, in demand, and so on.

So what lessons can be learned, and how do you get it right to start driving real engagement, leads and conversions from social media?

Social marketing done right

I'll say it again:

All Internet marketing starts with great content!

Before you even bother with social media, which can be very time consuming, expensive, and ultimately a huge waste of time if not done properly, learn how to create engaging and valuable content FIRST.

Even if you have tried your hand at social media before, if you aren't confident that your content is high quality and engaging, stop what you are doing and go back to the drawing board.

You aren't in the business of Internet marketing until you know how to create fantastic content that drives engagement!

I would suggest following these steps to get your social media strategy on track (regardless of whether it is YouTube, Twitter, Facebook, etc):

  1. Start identifying and segmenting target audiences
  2. Start creating valuable content that speaks to highly focused segments of your audience
  3. Analyze and refine your content and its performance
  4. Build up a broad and deep reservoir of great content on your own Web properties - i.e. blog, website, forums, etc
  5. Once you have established sufficient trust, authority, and followers via your content, start producing content focused on a specific social media platform
  6. Promote that content aggressively to get existing followers to adopt it
  7. Grow your content and engagement on one social media platform until you are confident that the process can be repeated on another, without endangering your current interests

This is fundamentally different process from the one adopted by big budget, big brand businesses, who approach the online medium the same way they approach TV or print.

For small business, recognizing that you have to earn trust and authority by providing great content is a less humbling experience, because you don't have to go back to the drawing board - unlike larger businesses.

In addition, because the online market is so vast, small businesses that do a good job with social media can make a very big dent in real world market shares.

So that's my analysis of how big brands are messing up social media and costing themselves a lot of advertising dollars for very little return.

But, I hope that I have also offered a sensible strategy to turn things around, and, over time, start to generate real engagement that will lead to plenty of prospects, conversions, and ultimately, profits.

What are your thoughts on big business social strategies? Share your thoughts and ideas in the comments.

top digital marketing questions

Online marketing is about much more than introducing carefully selected keywords and phrases into content to optimize for organic search; or build up backlin

Gathering useful articles from top influencers

Content fatigue, when it comes to finding innovative and creative marketing advice, is becoming a serious time burglar for me.

Check out this list of ten great hyperlocal marketing strategies, by Carlo Pandian, that can help to drive local consumers to your site.

Sample press release template. Pic by Matthew Guay

The other day I decided to get some coverage in the news - actually, I wanted to get some exposure for a particularly nice bit of research we'd done - and st

"Are you looking for some great content marketing strategies that will help to generate plenty of buzz around your blog posts and articles?"

Content marketing is not only important for getting your content read by other people.

One of its primary purposes is to help establish authority so that your content enjoys high page rankings and gets plenty of organic search traffic from Google.

How to increase site traffic an conversions. Pic by Tony Alter

Everyone knows that in order to make more money online you either have to increase the volumes of website traffic, or increase conversion rates (or both

3 common affiliate marketing mistakes

Starting an affiliate program to market your business online is a great way to get real growth - but it comes with dangers that you must manage pro-actively from the start.

By definition, affiliate marketing hands a degree of control over to the publishers who market on your behalf.

Because these publishers are incentivized with sales commissions, they may end up using advertising and promotional strategies that your own company might not be comfortable with.

Take an innovative approach to marketing

If you're in the business of making and selling unique stuff then the marketing strategies you use should reflect the creativity of your products in order to reach out to the right people.

Fortunately the Internet is full of the "right people" just waiting to place an order. But your message has to find them in the right place in the right way.

That's why it pays to think creatively about marketing instead of following the pack and doing the same old "tried and tested" things.

Drive traffic without SEO

I am an ardent supporter of creating great quality content that ranks well in Google search for marketing purposes.

Recently, however, I have been forced to concede that organic traffic from Google is no longer reliable enough.

Since 2012 Google's search results have been in upheaval, and while the general thrust of the changes are to improve search results and cut out spam, there has been significant collateral damage along the way.

Here's the thing about moving traditional customers online; you have to find innovative marketing strategies and ideas to get them to migrate.

great marketing ideas

Coming up with marketing ideas for small business can be a challenge.

How to work with social media effectively

Social media marketing is one of those things that most entrepreneurs and small business owners wonder if they really need.

In general, my answer is yes, but I need to qualify that by saying that the amount of time, effort and cash you invest must be proportional to the returns you want (and can realistically achieve).

I serve on the board of a wonderful not-for-profit, registered charity, and we have utilized the tools and technologies provided by the Web, and in particular, social media, to drive visibility, engagement, and awareness that would simply be out of reach otherwise.